Eric P. Butts

THE Career Site for Accountants and Consultants.

  • Home
  • About
  • Useful Resources
  • Articles
  • Work With Me
    • Breakthrough Resume Writing
    • How to Get Smart in Excel…Fast!
    • Corporate Ladder University (Book)
  • Login
You are here: Home / Career Advice / Workplace Utopia or Disaster in Progress?

January 13, 2014 by Eric Butts 1 Comment

Workplace Utopia or Disaster in Progress?

In case you haven’t heard, Zappos, one of my favorite companies (no promo), announced the end of managers at the company. Instead, they decided to implement a holacracy system (no managers). I didn’t even know such a word existed until I read about it in this article in the Washington Post*. Given the unusual nature of the change compared to anything I’ve seen, I wanted to know what kind of psycho person came up with this idea and what does it look like. I would think it doesn’t look like the Career Builder monkeys hanging out in the office like you see here, but I haven’t ruled it out as a possibility yet.


After taking a look at the benefits people say exist in this kind of egalitarian workplace, I have to call bs. A key element of holacracy is doing everything by committee. Considering how difficult it is to pick a restaurant with more than three people involved in the decision (at least for me), this sounds like the ultimate frustration to deal with every single day. On the other hand, this structure sounds like something good for people who avoid ownership at all costs if that’s your thing, but I have to warn you if that is your thing then we can’t be friends. I’m sorry.


The whole idea of a holacracy just leaves me with so many questions:


  1. Who decides how much money everyone makes?
  2. Who decides who sits on each committee?
  3. Who approves vacation days?
  4. How do you escalate any workplace issues and who would you even escalate to?
  5. What’s the workplace dating policy when subordinates don’t exist?
  6. Who even decides which committees are needed?
I could go on with all of my objections, but I also haven’t started any multi-million dollar businesses from scratch, so I could be wrong… 

Such a drastic shift in culture will take some time to ramp-up, so if Zappos is still committed to this and working to make it “stick” after a year, then I suspect Zappos’ new org will be there to stay, for better or worse. I know I’ll be dialed in to see which way it goes.

What do you think? Could you see your company moving to a holacracy? Could you see yourself operating in a holacracy? Let me know in the comments.


*How did I not know Jeff Bezos (founder and CEO of Amazon) owns the Washington Post now?! Is it just me or did that go under the radar?


Photo Credit: edkohler via CC

Filed Under: Career Advice

About Eric Butts

I’m a management consultant, MBA and CPA who has a passion for helping others in their career pursuits. Grab my FREE cheatsheet on 12 simple habits of highly successful consultants.

Comments

  1. Eric Butts says

    March 16, 2014 at 1:06 am

    Well said, Eric. Hopefully this nonsense doesn’t gain any traction.

    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Featured Posts

The Best and Worst Thing About Management Consulting

Treat your clients like terrorists and you’ll have a highly successful career (this has NOTHING to do with negotiation)

Motivating Employees: Take The Time to Meet Your People

5 Ways to Influence Gatekeepers Who Want Nothing to Do with You

How to Get Into Business School – Part 1 (GMAT)

Popular Posts

  • 5 Reasons You Should Be Proud to Ask Dumb Questions at Work
  • What Does It Mean to Have a Sense of Urgency
  • Always Stay Close to the Gatekeepers
  • Why Are There Still So Few Black CPAs?
  • What's the Difference Between FP&A and Accounting?
  • 3 Reasons Average Students Become Good Accountants
  • One Thing You Should Never Do on Linkedin
  • How to Handle Double Standards in the Workplace
  • How to Pass the CPA Exam Without Breaking the Bank
  • Masters in Accounting Isn't The Sweet Treat Some Students Think

Recent Posts

  • The 3 word Facebook post that has me feeling all kinds of motivated right now
  • I think I discovered the last fax machine this weekend (and a related lesson you should be immediately applying)
  • How to create your own luck in your career
  • Here’s why you may want to rethink that skills section on your resume
  • Internet troll triggered by a pair of tweets
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Disclaimer

© 2012–2021 Eric P. Butts